Rate Assignment: Research Paper on Climate Change

Evaluate this assignment using the Thering Framework for AI-proof assignments criteria. Rate each criterion from 1-3.

Rating Scale
1 - Ready for Updating

Needs significant improvement to align with AI-era learning goals

2 - Partially Aligned & Engaging

Has some good elements but could be strengthened

3 - Strongly Aligned & Engaging

Excellent example of AI-era assignment design

Assignment Content
Assignment: Climate Change Research Paper

Objective: Students will research and analyze climate change from multiple perspectives and develop evidence-based policy recommendations.

Requirements:
1. Research at least 5 peer-reviewed sources
2. Analyze causes, effects, and current mitigation strategies
3. Develop 3 specific policy recommendations
4. Include personal reflection on the research process
5. Submit a 2000-2500 word paper with proper citations

Assessment Criteria:
- Quality of research and sources (25%)
- Analysis depth and critical thinking (30%)
- Policy recommendations feasibility (25%)
- Writing quality and citations (20%)

Due Date: December 15, 2024
1. Alignment with Outcomes

How well does this assignment align with clear learning outcomes and provide authentic evidence of student learning?

Please select a rating for this criterion.
2. Cognitive Demand

Does this assignment require higher-order thinking that students (not AI) must demonstrate?

Please select a rating for this criterion.
3. Authenticity / Context

Is this assignment situated in real, disciplinary, or professional contexts that require judgment?

Please select a rating for this criterion.
4. Accessibility / Equity

Is this assignment accessible and equitable for all learners regardless of AI access?

Please select a rating for this criterion.
5. Process Visibility

Are student processes, including AI use, made visible and valued in this assignment?

Please select a rating for this criterion.
6. AI Transparency & Ethical Literacy

Does this assignment address AI use ethically and promote critical evaluation of AI-generated content?

Please select a rating for this criterion.
7. Teaching Methods

Do the teaching methods associated with this assignment actively engage students in AI-aware learning?

Please select a rating for this criterion.
Additional Information
Back to Assignment